A proposed retail and housing undertaking on Telegraph Avenue that is previously confirmed controversial with neighbors received its very first review very last week from Berkeley’s zoning board.
The gentleman powering the proposal is Patrick Kennedy, head of Berkeley-based Panoramic Pursuits, who is operating with Lowney Architecture on the strategies. The task proposes the demolition of a solitary-story building among Dwight Way and Parker Road and the construction of a 70-foot-tall 6-tale constructing to include sixty five rental models aimed at pupils, and 6,000 square feet of floor-floor retail. Six of people models would be accessible to very-minimal-income homes: individuals making no more than 50% of the region median revenue.
Thursday night’s preview session was the Zoning Adjustments Board‘s 1st opportunity to give opinions on the undertaking. No motion was scheduled or taken.
Kennedy described his undertaking to the board as “a bold and optimistic gesture” on Telegraph, which he stated is long overdue for advancements that are probably to appear as greater density housing is built on the avenue.
“I believe it’s time for a daring announcement that Telegraph Avenue is altering,” he stated.
[Disclosure: Panoramic Interests a sponsor of Berkeleyside’s once-a-year tips festival, Uncharted.]
Critics of the venture, at 2539 Telegraph, have taken issue with the prepare to demolish a creating that housed the nation’s initial disability advocacy team operate by people with disabilities and oriented toward aiding them stay independently the proposal’s parking prepare, which involves an 8-auto garage and place with racks for 65 bicycles and its height, especially on the Regent Street aspect of the parcel. (The project has frontage on each Telegraph and Regent.) About a dozen individuals, some of whom represented neighborhood associations, told the zoning board about their considerations Thursday evening.
Right up until about 2010, the Heart for Unbiased Dwelling operated out of the squat, unassuming building at 2539 Telegraph. The service and advocacy organization for men and women with disabilities moved into a new Berkeley headquarters at the Ed Roberts Campus, across from the Ashby BART station, when that facility opened in 2010.
Simply because of that historical past, in accordance to the staff report for very last week’s meeting, the building is eligible to be on the Countrywide Sign up of Historic Spots, but is not a selected city landmark. Study the city’s Historic Useful resource Evaluation of the home below.
Kennedy pays some homage towards that history in the identify of his new project, which is called “The Unbiased.” Thursday night time, there was also speak of the likelihood of a exhibit on website that would explain the property’s history.
The venture requires an environmental evaluation, which will allow for general public feedback and questions as strategies go ahead. In accordance to the personnel report: “Based on preliminary analysis, it appears that the project’s significant outcomes would be constrained to demolition of an historic resource, air good quality, and sound.”
A community comment time period is now underway by means of July 28, and another remark period will take place in Oct, according to the environmental evaluation schedule (see page 6).
The developer has requested for a density bonus, which enables taller projects below state legislation if reasonably priced units are presented on web site. That would press the venture up to 6 stories under the present layout. On common, the units — primarily two-bedrooms — would be 910 square toes in measurement, in accordance to venture programs. The “typical” unit would be about 640 square feet, with two bedrooms of about a hundred thirty five sq. feet each and every.
Commissioners requested, among other things, for the developer to occur back again with a “scaled back” version of the programs to better match in with Regent Road, as well as a more exclusive layout.
“It looked cookie cutter to me,” Commissioner Igor Tregub advised developer Kennedy. “I’ve observed some of your other operate and it’s been very elegant…. Probably existing one thing that not only suits in better with this community but tends to make some type of assertion, which I really don’t see here.”
Commissioners questioned the project’s strategy to parking, and mentioned they weren’t certain if the spot would be a excellent fit for a auto-totally free advancement. They suggested that a more considered-out transit management strategy — to incorporate bus passes or some variety of on-website car sharing arrangement, for instance — may possibly be in get. In accordance to the workers report, most of the venture would be constructed in a zone that does not need off-street parking, and which prohibits the issuance of parking permits for residents.
Commissioners also wondered about Kennedy’s approach to the format of the units, which function an alcove or “junior bedroom” that has no committed window, but is lit as an alternative by ambient mild from greater-than-common home windows elsewhere in the unit.
“These units will have a lot more light and far more air than virtually any housing in Berkeley,” Kennedy instructed the board. “It is a pleasant area and I am self-assured we will have numerous people happy to live there.”
He said the inside bedroom would be open fifty% to the relaxation of the device, and have its own ventilation. This fashion of design has turn into common in San Francisco, Kennedy additional.
Commissioner Bob Allen, a single of the much more development-helpful board customers, took specific umbrage at the device design. He explained Berkeley’s building code needs all residing regions and bedrooms to have their own all-natural light-weight and ventilation.
“This is no way fulfills that requirement,” Allen said. “As a large fan of what Patrick’s carried out for this town, I’m really shocked with the absence of respect with town coverage it displays in striving to drive this on to us.”
Commissioner Steven Donaldson disagreed with the naysayers, noting that he had frequented many San Francisco projects with junior-bedrooms, and discovered them desirable and more and more popular thanks to their overall flexibility.
Commissioner Denise Pinkston provided ideas for project improvements but stated she, way too, could see the prospects. She described a “lifestyle change” underway that has manufactured units with junior-bedrooms attractive to some.
“It is a way that we’re living now,” extra Commissioner Prakash Pinto. Even though he stated he was not confident no matter whether college students in Berkeley would be as intrigued in the proposed living arrangement as youthful affluent couples or one tenants in San Francisco. “At the stop of the day it’s even now a windowless bed room.”
Commissioner Sophie Hahn said the device layout essential work: “The measurement of the bedrooms borders on inhumane.” She explained the proposed layout is particularly troubling provided the site’s historical past as a location the place the disability legal rights movement began. She explained the bedrooms as “so little that you could not change a wheelchair about,” including, “There’s nothing listed here that tends to make it obtainable to people with disabilities.”
According to the workers report well prepared for Thursday night’s conference, 10 of the 29 sleeping regions on every flooring would not have their personal home windows. Workers famous this would most likely be an on-going situation of dialogue as the growth team seeks acceptance from the town to construct.
Neighbors on Regent Avenue mentioned they ended up especially concerned about the top of the task on that road and the lack of parking for the project. George Beier, symbolizing the Willard Neighborhood Association, said the project would be way out of scale on the “smaller-scale residential” block. He explained the task should be redesigned so it “steps down” to the decrease structures surrounding it for a far better transition.
Beier also explained there would be just 1 parking spot allotted to residents in The Unbiased, and said parking is already way too minimal in the neighborhood to allow that method.
“Telegraph Avenue could undoubtedly use a shot in the arm, but I really don’t think we should shoot Regent Avenue in the head,” he instructed the zoning board Thursday.
Phil Bokovoy informed the board that the proposed density — in conditions of bedrooms for each acre — is much also higher for the community, and stated a three-story building would fit in much better with the location.
“I have walked by that website for thirty a long time now,” he mentioned. “I agree that that’s a great web site for growth, but I think this venture is actually out of scale.”
Extra Dean Metzger of the Berkeley Neighborhoods Council: “This building is going to overwhelm the neighborhood.… Most folks are not going to want to live there anymore.”
Other individuals who spoke echoed people identical issues, and also requested about what would come about to a pocket park on Regent Avenue that experienced been open to the community in the previous. Kennedy said that green space was fenced off ten many years back, and that it would be utilized to develop an “attractive edge” for the project.
He told the board he’s investigating the likelihood of employing prefabricated modules to create the venture quicker and reduce down on development charges. He said has not manufactured a closing decision but, even so, and that he is bidding out the perform each methods — with both prefabricated and conventional developing methods.
He observed that, in the past 38 many years, there have been no residential initiatives developed on Telegraph. He pointed, in distinction, to downtown Berkeley’s modern housing growth and the improved vibrancy in the location as a result.
“The constant and palpable decline of Telegraph is, in some evaluate, attributable to an antidevelopment attitude,” he informed the board. “That street…sorely wants our assist.”
Commissioners said it would consider some significant changes before any permits could be granted.
“There’s a permittable task someplace,” Hahn advised the improvement group. “I don’t consider this is it.”
The venture was at first submitted to the city in December, appeared ahead of the Landmarks Preservation Fee and zoning board before this thirty day period, and is heading just before the Design and style Overview Committee on Thursday night.
See a lot more of the task files for 2539 Telegraph Ave. on the town internet site. Individuals with concerns or responses about the task can direct them to city planner Aaron Sage via electronic mail at email@example.com or telephone, 510-981-7425.
Berkeley Chamber awards very first Visionary awards (10.03.13)
1,000 new residences planned for downtown Berkeley (02.07.thirteen)
Acheson Commons: Big change for downtown (04.09.twelve)
Berkeley developer sees foreseeable future in tiny, sensible homes (03.08.12)
Get the newest Berkeley information in your inbox with Berkeleyside’s cost-free Day-to-day Briefing. And make confident to bookmark Berkeleyside’s web pages on Fb and Twitter. You do not need an account on individuals sites to view critical information.